Insights

November 2, 2026

How to Get More Google Reviews: Why Recency Beats a Perfect Star Rating

A 5.0 rating isn't enough. Learn why review count and recency decide who gets the call, plus a simple, Google-compliant system to keep reviews coming.

A lot of great Las Vegas businesses have a perfect 5.0 on Google and still lose the call to a competitor down the street. The reason usually isn't the quality of the work. It's how many reviews they have, and how recent the newest one is.

Several marketers covered this in videos this week. Here is what they said, and how we'd apply it to a local business.

A perfect rating isn't the whole story

Adam Erhart walked through a real search for tree services in Grand Rapids, Michigan. One company, Ascend Tree Service, had a perfect 5.0 rating with 11 reviews and showed up on page two. A competitor, Simple Tree Services, also had a perfect 5.0, but with 170 reviews.

His framing is the useful part: "both businesses have a perfect 5.0... the difference here is not the quality." When two listings tie on stars, customers compare the next things they can see: how many reviews there are, and how recent they are.

In a second video, Erhart pointed to a pest control company in Columbus, Ohio, in business for more than 80 years with 98 Google reviews, while a much newer competitor had over 5,000. His read: "somebody at the newer company is asking every single customer for a review, and nobody at the older company is."

Look at recency, not just the total

Erhart's most practical tip is to sort a listing's reviews by newest. In his tree service example, Ascend's newest review was seven months old, and it had received two reviews in the last 12 months. Simple's newest was about a week old, with 20 reviews in the same 12 months, roughly two a month.

A homeowner scrolling on their phone sees those dates too. A business whose last review is seven months old looks very different from one reviewed last week, even if the work is identical.

Try it on your own listing today. Sort by newest and count how many reviews came in during the last year. Then do the same for the competitor you lose jobs to most often.

Reviews now feed AI recommendations too

Sabri Suby made a related point about AI search. When people ask ChatGPT or other AI tools who's best in their area, he says those tools don't just read your website. They look at press, journalists and reviews on platforms like Google. In his words, "your brand is largely about what other people say about you, not just what you say about yourself."

His suggested test: ask ChatGPT or Claude "who is the best in my location" for your service and see who it recommends. If you're missing, reviews are one of the signals worth working on. (We cover the rest in our guide to getting recommended by ChatGPT.)

A sign at the counter isn't asking

Erhart describes the owner who says, "I already tried asking for reviews. It doesn't work." When you look closer, the owner put up a sign or printed a line on an invoice. His point: "putting up a little sign isn't asking for reviews. A text that goes directly to the customer the day the job is done with the right link... that's asking."

Most customers who don't leave a review aren't unhappy. They meant to and forgot.

A simple, compliant review system

Erhart lays out a three-message flow that any business can run by hand or with software:

  1. 1A check-in, with no ask. Right after the job: "Just checking in to make sure everything looks good." This also surfaces problems early so you can fix them.
  2. 2The review request. A few hours later, a short message with your Google review link, using the customer's first name and yours so it reads like a real person wrote it.
  3. 3One reminder. Only if they haven't clicked the link. Erhart says this reminder is "where a huge share of the reviews actually come in." Then stop.

Two rules matter here:

  • Send the same request to everyone. Erhart warns that sending happy customers to Google and unhappy customers somewhere private "is called review gating and it's not allowed."
  • Never pay or reward people for reviews. TAAM doesn't recommend it for any client. Earn them by asking every customer, every time.

Don't forget past customers

Erhart also suggests a "review reactivation" step: slowly sending review requests to past customers who were never asked. He says that, in his experience, roughly 8 to 15% of those customers leave a review. Spread the requests out rather than blasting a whole list at once.

Reply to your reviews

When reviews come in, answer them. Erhart notes that a business that responds to every review builds trust with people comparing listings. In the Columbus example, the owner had replied to exactly one review, four years earlier. A short, personal reply to each new review shows future customers that a real person is paying attention.

What to expect

Be careful with promises. Erhart's rule is "promise the work, never the rankings." Google decides rankings, and customers decide whether to post. What you control is asking every customer, consistently, and showing up well when people look.

Next step for Las Vegas businesses

Run our free Google Business Profile audit to see where your listing stands, then compare your last-12-months review count to your top competitor. If the gap is big, the fix is usually a system, not better work. And if you want help showing what your work looks like, try a free week of video from TAAM.

Questions, answered.

Does the number of Google reviews matter if I already have a 5.0 rating?

Adam Erhart's examples suggest it does. When two businesses both show 5.0 stars, customers compare how many reviews each has and how recent they are, so a 5.0 with 11 reviews can lose to a 5.0 with 170.

What is review gating?

Review gating means sending only happy customers to your Google review link and steering unhappy ones somewhere private. Adam Erhart notes it is not allowed, so send the same review request to every customer.

How many times should I ask a customer for a review?

Erhart recommends a check-in message, one review request, and a single reminder only if the customer hasn't clicked the link. After that, stop.

Can I offer customers something in return for a review?

TAAM never recommends paying or rewarding customers for reviews. Ask every customer consistently and make it easy with a direct link.

Let's make your
customers say wow.